Text 1
Over the past fifteen years, dozens of mid-sized cities have added networks of protected bike lanes, separated from car traffic by curbs or concrete planters. A team of transportation researchers compared traffic fatality records from cities that built such networks with records from similar cities that did not. In cities with the new lanes, deaths among all road users, including drivers and pedestrians, fell by about a third, while the comparison cities saw little change. The researchers conclude that protected lanes themselves make streets safer for everyone, perhaps because narrower car lanes encourage drivers to slow down, and they urge city governments to treat the lanes as a top priority for road-safety spending.
Text 2
Cities rarely build protected bike lanes in isolation. An urban planning scholar reviewing the same period found that most cities adding the lanes also lowered speed limits, redesigned dangerous intersections, and lengthened the time pedestrians were given to cross, often as parts of a single safety plan approved in the same year. Because these changes arrived together, she argues, records of fatalities cannot show how much of the improvement any single measure produced. She does not dispute that the streets became safer. In several cities, she notes, the lanes were the most visible part of the plan, which may explain why they received most of the public credit. But a city that builds lanes without the accompanying changes, she cautions, should not expect the same results.