For decades, ornithologists have noticed that members of a common songbird species living in cities sing at higher pitches than members of the same species living in forests. The most widely accepted explanation is acoustic: traffic noise is concentrated at low frequencies, so birds that raise their pitch can be heard over the rumble, and young males then learn these higher songs from the adults around them. A team of biologists has proposed a different account. In their view, the shift has less to do with what the birds hear than with what they eat. Urban birds, the team notes, rely heavily on feeders stocked with seeds, whereas forest birds feed mostly on caterpillars. Because a caterpillar diet supplies more of certain fats that support the growth of the vocal organ, the team argues, forest-raised birds develop larger vocal structures, which naturally produce lower notes. City birds, raised largely on seeds, develop smaller structures and therefore sing higher, regardless of how noisy their surroundings are. To support this idea, the researchers point to measurements showing that the vocal organs of urban birds are, on average, slightly smaller than those of forest birds. Critics respond that this size difference is small and could result from other features of city life. The team acknowledges the criticism but maintains that diet, rather than noise, is the main cause of the pitch difference, and it has begun a series of aviary experiments to test its claim directly.