Text 1
Across much of Europe, regional dialects that once differed sharply from village to village have been fading for more than a century. Many observers attribute this leveling to broadcast media. As radio and later television reached nearly every household, the argument goes, listeners grew used to hearing a single standard variety of their language for hours each day. Children in particular, who absorb speech patterns readily, began to model their pronunciation and vocabulary on newscasters and actors rather than on older relatives. In this view, the rapid spread of national broadcasting in the mid-twentieth century explains why dialect loss accelerated so sharply during those same decades, and the constant presence of screens in daily life ensures that the process will continue.
Text 2
Sociolinguists who have tracked individual speakers over many years report a different pattern. People rarely adopt new pronunciations from voices they only hear; they adopt them from people they talk with. In one long-term study of a farming region, residents who watched the most television showed no more change in their speech than residents who watched very little. The strongest predictor of change was instead whether a speaker had moved to a city for work or school and formed friendships there. Broadcast media may make a standard variety familiar, these researchers argue, but familiarity alone seems to do little to alter the way someone actually speaks. The decline of dialects, they suggest, owes more to the movement of people than to the movement of signals.