Text 1
Some urban planners argue that converting traffic lanes into protected bike lanes harms local businesses, because shoppers who arrive by car will have fewer places to park and will simply go elsewhere. On this view, merchants along busy streets are right to oppose such projects, since their customers depend on easy access by car.
Text 2
A team of transportation researchers studied sales records from shops on twelve streets before and after bike lanes were added. On most of the streets, total sales stayed level or rose slightly. The researchers found that cyclists and pedestrians tended to spend less per visit than drivers did but visited more often, so their overall spending was comparable. The team concluded that fears about lost business, while understandable, were not supported by the data from these streets.