Reading & Writing · 모듈 2 · 문항 14
A group of eleven unsigned landscape paintings, all made in the same coastal region during the early 1700s, has puzzled art historians for decades. The works vary in size and subject: some show harbors crowded with ships, others show empty dunes under storm clouds. Art historian Lucien Marchetti argues that all eleven were produced in a single workshop. His central evidence is chemical. Laboratory analysis revealed that every painting contains a distinctive blue pigment made by grinding a mineral that, as far as geologists know, was mined in only one valley in the region. Because none of the other paintings from that period that Marchetti's team tested contain the pigment, he reasons that the eleven works must share a common origin, most likely a workshop with private access to the valley's mine. Several scholars find the argument persuasive, though some have asked whether the pigment could have reached painters through other channels.
Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken Marchetti's claim?
- A. Several of the eleven paintings depict scenes that appear in no other known works from the region.
- B. Merchant records show that the blue pigment was sold to many independent painters throughout the region.
- C. The mineral used to make the blue pigment was more expensive than most other materials painters used.
- D. X-ray images reveal that several of the eleven paintings have underdrawings made with the same technique.